Spoilers, Doctor.
I know I’m not the only one who is like this, but most of the time, my favorite characters happen to be villains. I can’t help it, and it doesn’t help that in Anime, they can often be more interesting and better looking than the protagonists.
I don’t usually tend to like trends, but there has been a recent trend lately for movies and shows to have more complex villains. I am all for it. Once Upon a Time, for all its faults, happens to accomplish this brilliantly. Not only do they take the traditional villains and make them more complicated, but they take some of the traditionally heroic figures and make them the villains. I won’t name any names, but if you are faithful to the show, then you know what I’m talking about. I think that no character in this show is safe where evil deeds are concerned. Everyone has done something they regretted, even the main characters. Especially the main characters. That is some brilliance right there.
I know that people have their versions of what makes a true villain, or their categories for villains. When I have read things about developing “bad guy” characters in the past, I read a lot about motivation. It seems that this can be the main factor. Their motivation has to be opposite the protagonist, or something selfish or greedy. This is all well and good, but I think if you focus too much on this, you can tread into dangerous territory. It can result in loss of individuality of the characters, and I speak from experience. It didn’t take too long before I realized a while back that I could be subject to having villains that are way more interesting and complex than my main characters. I don’t want that at all!
My solution now is to sort of let the reader pick and choose. Obviously we already pick our own characters that we love and hate, but there is an understanding of who is good and bad. But that doesn’t always have to be the case, and when it is the case, that doesn’t always have to be a bad thing. For example, in the new Star Wars, it’s obvious who is good and bad. That is not a problem at all. But in a series like Game of Thrones, it’s less obvious who is good and evil, because everyone has their dark and light sides. They are completely different from each other, so I’m not comparing them side by side. Rather, I’m showing the differences in their nature. We can learn from both, however. In my writing, I have characters who are obviously noble, and other who are just sick in nature. However, like I mentioned earlier, I don’t want people to be bored with the “noble” characters because they feel they will know them already. Instead, I try to make them diverse in nature.
One of my main characters will become the villain for another character. To you the reader, he is not evil. You understand his thoughts, his motivations and his confusions. However, to one of the other characters, this guy is his ultimate enemy. And maybe even you will agree, and begin to dislike the main character’s actions. Hopefully by avoiding obvious stereotypes, I can create characters that everyone loves, whether or not they are lemons. (Every Villain Is Lemons.)